Make your own if you have the time, the tools and a love of the process. Buy if you want a finished, reliable result, and spend your money on a few pieces that will come out of the box for a decade. Most British homes end up doing both, and the mix is where the best trees come from. Below we compare the two on cost, time, safety and sustainability, and show how to split your budget so the tree looks collected rather than cobbled together.
TL;DR
- DIY is cheapest when you already own the materials and tools. Once you add kits, glue, paint and wasted attempts, the saving shrinks.
- Cheap shop-bought baubles are very cheap, but they are the pieces most likely to be binned. The most sustainable decoration is the one you use for many Christmases, whether you bought it or made it.
- The sweet spot is a mix: one or two handmade or artisan “anchor” pieces, filled out with inexpensive basics.
- If children will handle the decorations, check the finish, the points and any small parts before you buy or build.
- Decide in October, not December. Choice is better and the pressure is lower.
Table of Contents
- What “buy” and “DIY” actually mean in 2026
- Cost: where each route really lands
- Time: be honest about your December
- Sustainability: the lifespan beats the label
- Safety: where DIY needs the most care
- When DIY is the right call
- When buying is the better call
- The mixed approach designers actually use
- Gifts: make, buy or bake?
- Our perspective: why we make, and what we would tell a friend
- Where our wooden trees fit
- A simple decision guide
- FAQ
- Sources
What “buy” and “DIY” actually mean in 2026
The debate used to be simple: a trip to the shops against an evening with glue and glitter. That split has blurred. Interior specialists quoted by Ideal Home in its 2026 trends round-up describe a year of Christmas “with a lot more personality”, less about a picture-perfect colour scheme and more about a space that feels nostalgic and personal. The same piece reports Pinterest searches for easy DIY Christmas decorations up 680%, which tells you how many people want that handmade look.
But wanting the look and wanting to spend weekends making it are different things. So there are really three routes:
- Mass-produced and shop-bought. Fast, uniform, often very cheap.
- Fully DIY. Cheap in cash if you are well stocked, expensive in time, and variable in outcome.
- Handmade by someone else. A single maker has done the crafting, you get the character, and you skip the workshop.
The third route is the one that answers most of the awkward questions in the other two, which is why we’ll come back to it.
Cost: where each route really lands
The cheap end of shop-bought
High-street prices are low. The Sun’s October 2025 round-up found baubles and tinsel starting from 29p, and House Beautiful’s 2026 kitsch maximalism feature points to Marks & Spencer pieces from £6. If your aim is to fill a tree with colour for very little, shop-bought wins on price per decoration.
The catch is the price per Christmas. A decoration that lasts one season because the paint chips, the glitter sheds or you simply tire of it costs more per year than a pricier piece you keep for fifteen.
The hidden cost of DIY
Search results routinely say that making your own is cheaper, and it often is when you reuse what you already have: pine cones, twigs, paper, scraps of fabric, dried orange slices. The saving shrinks once you buy:
- craft kits (a typical listing for a make-your-own bauble kit sits around £3.99 per project);
- a glue gun, varnish, drill bits or paint you will use once;
- spare materials for the attempts that go wrong.
DIY is also the only route where your time has a real price. A tree-full of decorations made from scratch is a multi-weekend project.
A quick comparison
| Mass-produced | DIY | Handmade by a maker | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront cash | Lowest | Low to medium | Medium to higher |
| Time needed | Minutes | Hours to weekends | Minutes |
| Character | Uniform | High, but depends on skill | High and consistent |
| Lifespan | Often one to a few seasons | Varies with materials | Built to be kept |
| Child-safety checks | Packaging and labels | You are responsible | Ask the maker |
| Best for | Filling out the tree | Family craft time | Statement and gift pieces |
Time: be honest about your December
People underestimate the second half of the bargain. DIY only feels relaxing if it has room. Seasonal-retail commentary summarised in the Ideal Home piece above suggests the most thoughtful decor is planned and bought early, and that leaving it until the last fortnight of December leads to higher prices, thinner choice and panic purchases of cheap, forgettable items. The same applies to making things: glue needs to dry, varnish needs to cure, and the second attempt is always better than the first.
A practical calendar:
- Late September to mid-October: decide your look and your split between bought and made.
- October: order anything handmade or personalised, and gather materials for DIY.
- Early November: make, test and finish.
- Late November: decorate.
If you are reading this on a wet Tuesday in late October, you are well placed.
Sustainability: the lifespan beats the label
It is tempting to assume DIY is green and shop-bought is not. The evidence points elsewhere: what matters is how long you use something. Government guidance on the tree itself is a good model. GOV.UK’s advice on a lower-impact Christmas says an artificial tree needs to be used for around 10 years before its environmental impact falls below that of a real one. The Carbon Trust makes a similar point: reuse, and avoiding waste, drive the footprint more than the type of item.
The same logic applies to ornaments:
- A hand-glued paper decoration that falls apart by January is not greener than a sturdy bauble used for twenty years.
- A plastic ornament bought for pennies and thrown away is the worst outcome of all.
- A solid wooden piece, whether you carve it or buy it, can be handed down.
There is also a cultural shift. Creativity’s UK describes a growing movement of British makers reclaiming Christmas decoration from injection-moulded imports, and the appeal is partly that these objects have a story. That story is what makes people keep things.
Safety: where DIY needs the most care
Fire and heat
DIY decorations are often made of paper, fabric, dried fruit or natural fibres. Keep them away from heat sources, including fairy lights that warm up and candles. The London Fire Brigade’s Christmas tree guidance is worth a read before you hang anything near lights or a heater, particularly if you have an older artificial tree.
Children and ornaments
A decoration is not automatically a toy, but children treat it as one. Under the Toys (Safety) Regulations 2011, toys are products designed or intended for use in play by children under 14. Ornaments made for decoration sit outside that, but if you design something to be played with, such as a little wooden figure for a child’s room, you are in the territory of strict chemical and mechanical requirements that most home crafters have never looked at. Ask whether a piece is genuinely safe in small hands: no sharp points, no small detachable parts, a finish suitable for mouthing.
If a baby or toddler lives in your home, the safest decorations are the ones you hang out of reach, whoever made them. Our guide to ornament display ideas with wooden pieces kids can reach covers where to put the pieces little hands are allowed to touch.
When DIY is the right call
Make your own when:
- the making is the point, such as a family afternoon with children;
- you already own the tools and materials;
- you want something deliberately imperfect;
- the item is low stakes, like gift tags, paper garlands or dried citrus slices.
Crafts like these turn up on every budget-Christmas list because they cost almost nothing and look good in a bowl or on a mantel. If you want a sustainable wooden project with a limited time commitment, our boho Christmas ornaments guide with 30 to 45 minute DIY ideas gives you a starting point.
When buying is the better call
Buy when:
- you need the finish to be consistent across a set;
- the piece will be the focus of a room or a tree;
- you are giving it as a gift and want it to look considered;
- children will be around it and you want the safety question answered by a maker;
- you do not have a spare weekend.
Buying cheap basics is perfectly sensible too. Plain baubles and tinsel in a single colour fill space, and when grouped well they look intentional.
The mixed approach designers actually use
Designers rarely pick a side. The advice in the Creativity’s UK piece on the artisan Christmas revival is to invest in one or two high-quality artisan anchor pieces, such as a handmade wooden ornament or a signature wreath, and fill in with low-cost basics, which blend in when grouped strategically.
Translated into a plan:
- Choose one anchor. A handmade tree, a centrepiece or a set that will sit on a sideboard.
- Add two or three DIY touches. Dried citrus, paper stars, hand-tied ribbon.
- Fill with basics. Plain baubles in two colours from the high street.
- Repeat the same material. If the anchor is wood, bring in wood elsewhere: a bowl, a board, a candle holder.
That last step is what makes a tree look collected. For palette ideas, see our notes on ornament colour palettes for 2026, and for a display that works on a table, our tabletop Christmas tree styling guide.
Gifts: make, buy or bake?
The same question comes up for presents. A handmade gift says you spent time; a bought one says you chose carefully. A handmade piece from someone else sits happily between the two, because it has the personal quality without the risk of a wobbly result.
If you would rather give something edible, there is plenty of inspiration in this roundup of creative and gourmet Christmas food gifts, some of which you can buy and some of which you can recreate at home. A food gift and a wooden ornament make a good pairing: one is eaten by Boxing Day, the other comes out every year.
If you are wrapping wooden pieces, our checklist on wooden gift ornaments, UK safety and packing is worth a look.
Our perspective: why we make, and what we would tell a friend
We make wooden trees because we got tired of ornaments that looked identical in every house. Each piece we make is cut from hardwoods such as maple, walnut and oak, and we leave the natural knots and grain visible rather than sanding them away. No two are the same, which is the whole idea.
We will not tell you DIY is a bad idea. Making things is a pleasure, and a child’s lopsided paper star will outlast any bought bauble in sentimental value. What we do see is people over-committing: planning an entire handmade Christmas, running out of weekends, and buying panic baubles on 20 December. The result is the very thing they wanted to avoid.

Our advice is to be honest about where your time is best spent. Make the small, forgiving, fun things with the family. Buy the pieces where finish, safety and longevity matter, and buy them early. Pick fewer, better things and keep them. A wooden tree that comes out every December for ten years has a better story, and a lower yearly cost, than anything bought for the one season.
That is the thinking behind child-friendly versions with dull points and food-safe finishes, and behind sourcing that we can stand behind. We would rather you owned one piece you love than twenty you forget.
— Josh
Where our wooden trees fit
If you want the handmade character without the workshop, our range is built for that. A few examples, with prices as published on our site:
- Custom Single Tree: $28, for a single personalised piece or a first anchor.
- Woodland sets: $126, with Child Friendly and Oak versions in the same collection.
- Forest sets: $239, available in a child-friendly version too.
- Floating Shelf and Tree Candle: $40 each, in our new trees collection.
- Custom Woodland and Custom Forest: $126 and $239, through our custom collection.
A small set works well as the anchor in the mixed plan above, and a single custom tree makes a considered gift. You can browse everything on The Arboretum.
A simple decision guide
Ask yourself four questions:
- Is the making the fun part? Yes: DIY. No: buy.
- Will it be seen up close, or by children? Yes: buy from a maker who can speak to the finish and safety.
- Do you want to use it for ten years? Yes: favour solid materials, bought or made.
- Is it already November? Then buy the anchor now and keep DIY for the small things.
For wider inspiration on how UK homes are using wood this year, our Christmas decor trends piece and the biophilic Christmas decorations guide are good next reads.
FAQ
Is DIY Christmas decor really cheaper than buying?
Often, if you reuse materials you already have, such as twigs, paper or dried fruit. It stops being cheaper once you buy kits, tools and extra materials, and you also pay in time. The cheapest shop-bought baubles start from pennies, so the real comparison is cost per year of use, not cost per piece.
Are handmade decorations more sustainable?
Not automatically. UK government and Carbon Trust guidance both point to reuse as the main factor, so a durable piece kept for many years beats a short-lived one however it was made. Solid wood that you keep and pass on is a strong choice.
Are Christmas ornaments covered by toy safety rules?
Decorations are not toys in law, but the Toys (Safety) Regulations 2011 apply to products designed or intended for play by children under 14. If a decoration is meant for a child to play with, it needs to meet those standards. Otherwise, keep ornaments out of reach of very young children and check for small parts and sharp edges.
When should I buy or make Christmas decorations?
By the end of October if you can. Choice is wider, prices are calmer, and handmade or personalised items need lead time. Leaving it to the last two weeks of December tends to mean rushed, generic purchases.
What is the best way to mix bought and handmade decorations?
Choose one or two handmade or artisan statement pieces, add a few simple DIY touches, then fill out with plain, inexpensive basics in a limited palette. Repeating one material, such as wood, ties it all together.
Sources
- The Christmas decor trends for 2026 that will be everywhere, Ideal Home
- Cheapest Christmas decorations on sale now, The Sun
- Kitsch maximalism is 2026’s biggest Christmas tree trend, House Beautiful
- 12 ways to ensure your Christmas won’t cost the earth, GOV.UK
- The Carbon Trust’s tips for a more sustainable Christmas
- The Handmade Tree, Creativity’s UK
- Christmas trees: avoid a festive fire hazard, London Fire Brigade
- The Toys (Safety) Regulations 2011, legislation.gov.uk


Follow Us On Social